Electricity markets

Capacity mechanisms, contracts-for-differences, the EU electricity market reform, network codes: the design of European power markets is being renegotiated on many fronts at once. High wind and solar shares, recurring price spikes (both positive and negative), and political interventions raise questions of incentives, distributional consequences, and robust system operations.

We advise ministries, regulators, grid operators, and companies on market design, capacity mechanisms, and forward markets – through studies, expert reports, and courses. For the German government, we have recently worked on capacity markets, demand flexibility, locational price signals, and support schemes. Lion Hirth is our lead on electricity markets.

Eurelectric PV Austria 50Hertz CF Flex Power Bundesministerium für Wirtschaft und Energie Amprion Baltic Cable TenneT TransnetBW Europäisches Parlament Bundesnetzagentur Ørsted

Studies in electricity markets

Marginal pricing

Marginal pricing
Eurelectric · 2026

Marginal pricing

Eurelectric · 2026

The debate about marginal pricing and the “merit order” has flared up again, with policymakers proposing wholesale interventions echoing the “Iberian Mechanism.” For the industry association Eurelectric, we produced a short study benchmarking prices against other markets, explaining marginal pricing, and debunking key merit-order misconceptions.

Read the study ▸

Regional wholesale prices

Regional wholesale prices
Enercity · 2026

Regional wholesale prices

Enercity · 2026

Few energy policy questions are debated so fiercely as the split of the German bidding zone: the wholesale market is blind to grid congestion, leading to inefficient dispatch, costly redispatch, and distorted cross-border trade. For the utility Enercity, we delivered a study on the pros and cons of uniform, zonal, and nodal pricing.

Read the study ▸

Price spikes

Price spikes
50Hertz · 2025

Price spikes

50Hertz · 2025

Episodes of extremely high power prices have raised concerns about capacity withholding. For TSO 50Hertz, we evaluated the economic causes of extreme prices, including whether plant operators withheld capacity to artificially inflate them, and developed practical recommendations to prevent future price spikes and mitigate their effects on consumers.

Read the study ▸

Cross-border forward markets

Cross-border forward markets
TSOs · 2024

Cross-border forward markets

TSOs · 2024

European TSOs issue long-term transmission rights, and ACER has proposed numerous changes, including the establishment of a virtual hub. In a report for the German TSOs, we developed an analytical framework for cross-border forward markets and evaluated these proposals.

Read the study ▸

Electricity market reform

Electricity market reform
European Parliament · 2023

Electricity market reform

European Parliament · 2023

The 2023 EU electricity market reform sparked debate over CfDs, PPAs, price caps, and peak shaving. Together with Bruegel, we assessed the reform proposals for the European Parliament’s ITRE committee, based on a quantitative model of contractual arrangements, and derived recommendations.

Read the study ▸

Nodal vs. zonal pricing

Nodal vs. zonal pricing
BMWi · 2018

Nodal vs. zonal pricing

BMWi · 2018

Nodal vs. zonal pricing (BMWi). Zonal and nodal pricing represent transmission limits in the wholesale market in fundamentally different ways. For Germany’s economics ministry, with Consentec, Ecofys, Connect, Frontier Economics, Öko-Institut, and Prognos, we compared the two against a catalog of criteria and organized a series of expert workshops.

Read the study ▸

Electricity market design

Electricity market design
IEA-RETD · 2016

Electricity market design

IEA-RETD · 2016

How should power markets be designed when variable renewables dominate? For IEA-RETD, in cooperation with FTI CL Energy, we assessed long-term wholesale and retail market design under very high renewable shares, studying four power system prototypes from energy-only to vertically integrated markets.

Read the study ▸

Courses on electricity markets

Electricity Markets (EN)
An in-depth overview of how electricity markets function in practice, combining economic theory, regulation, and industry experience: from price formation and day-ahead auctions to balancing and capacity markets. Designed for professionals who trade, regulate, analyze, or design electricity markets across the power sector.

Grundlagen der Energiewirtschaft (DE)
Eine kompakte Einführung in Energie- und Netzwirtschaft sowie den politisch-regulatorischen Rahmen. Der Kurs vermittelt ein grundlegendes Verständnis von Stromsystem, Marktmechanismen und Regulierung. Für Berufs- und Quereinsteiger bei Energieversorgern und Netzbetreibern sowie in Projektentwicklung und Energiepolitik.

Project references on electricity markets

Marginal pricing (Eurelectric). The debate about marginal pricing and the “merit order” has flared up again, with policymakers proposing wholesale interventions echoing the “Iberian Mechanism.” For the industry association Eurelectric, we produced a short study benchmarking prices against other markets, explaining marginal pricing, and debunking key merit-order misconceptions. 2026. Report ▸

Austrian electricity market design (multi client). The rapid transformation of the power system keeps raising new market design questions. For Austrian renewable energy associations, we ran workshops on current topics in electricity market design, such as system-friendly operation and capacity markets. 2025–26.

Price spikes (50Hertz). Episodes of extremely high power prices have raised concerns about capacity withholding. For TSO 50Hertz, we evaluated the economic causes of extreme prices, including whether plant operators withheld capacity to artificially inflate them, and developed practical recommendations to prevent future price spikes and mitigate their effects on consumers. 2025. Report ▸

Electricity surplus (trading house). Rapid renewables growth with insufficient curtailment raises the probability that the day-ahead market fails to clear – the case when supply exceeds demand even at −500 €/MWh. For a trading house, we developed a model forecasting the probability of such events. 2025.

EU electricity market design (BMWE). European legislation shapes electricity markets, and more change is coming. This Consentec-led project provides support and advice for Germany’s energy ministry in upcoming EU electricity market negotiations, from support schemes to grid fees and capacity mechanisms. The goal: the cornerstones of a decarbonized EU electricity market. Ongoing.

Capacity market (BMWE). After a political decision to introduce a capacity market, this multi-year project develops such a market for Germany’s economics ministry. It examines options from a hedging obligation to a central capacity market. Consentec coordinates the overall project with r2b and Öko-Institut; we lead the work on hedging obligations. 2024–26.

Cross-border forward markets (TSOs). European TSOs issue long-term transmission rights, and ACER has proposed numerous changes, including the establishment of a virtual hub. In a report for the German TSOs, we developed an analytical framework for cross-border forward markets and evaluated these proposals. 2023–24. Report ▸

Electricity market reform (European Parliament). The 2023 EU electricity market reform sparked debate over CfDs, PPAs, price caps, and peak shaving. Together with Bruegel, we assessed the reform proposals for the European Parliament’s ITRE committee, based on a quantitative model of contractual arrangements, and derived recommendations. 2023. Report ▸

Revenue cap implementation (BNetzA). Germany’s energy regulator was tasked with implementing the revenue cap on power generators. Along with Frontier Economics, we provided economic expertise. 2023.

Electricity market design (utility). The EU market design reform raised strategic questions for power producers. We supported a European utility with analytics and assessments, focusing on offshore wind topics such as CfD design and transmission access guarantees. 2022–23.

EU electricity market design (BMWK). In this multi-year project for Germany’s economics ministry, we advised on EU electricity market reform and crisis response. With Consentec, Neon co-led the consortium (with Fraunhofer ISI, r2b, SUER), headed the core market-design work package, and shaped Germany’s position on Fit-for-55 and emergency measures, opposing harmful price interventions. 2021–24.

Academic publications related to electricity markets

Hirth (2013): The market value of variable renewables
Hirth & Ueckerdt (2013): Redistribution effects of energy and climate policy
Hirth (2015): The optimal share of variable renewables
Hirth et al. (2015): Integration costs revisited
Hirth et al. (2016): Why wind is not coal
Hirth (2018): What caused the drop of European electricity prices?
Blume-Werry et al. (2021): Eyes on the price: price-setting technologies
Hirth et al. (2024): Demand response to hourly wholesale prices
Stiewe et al. (2025): Cross-border cannibalization of wind & solar
Canales et al. (2026): Empirical estimate of the electricity supply curve